As I sorted and sifted through years of accumulated stuff, I found a few things to share on the cupcake. Today's theme is "Holy Crap."
This is from the weekly bulletin of the Catholic church down the street from about a year ago (I'm pretty sure M&D were visiting... really I'm not a churchie... I mean, I didn't inhale... Okay, so I took communion... Busted, I go to church sometimes.). For those of you not familiar with this type of publication, it's generally a 4-6 page leaflet with mass intentions for the coming week, lists of events (raffles, retreats, fundraisers, etc.), a directory of local businesses that donate money to the church, and an op/ed piece from a regional clergy member. The last of these is often either an insipid "true" story about faith (...and after meeting that child who lost his limbs/eyesight/parents in ____ [fill in blank disaster] I knew it was the work of God because said child filled all he met with hope/purpose/faith in the Lord...) or it is a call to arms for Catholics to live right/fight sin.
So... I was very pleasantly surprised to open up the bulletin to find the following. Am I reading this right? Is this what pro-choice Catholicism looks like?

Okay, so perhaps not pro-choice, but it is nice to see someone in the church willing to engage in the real struggles between accepting a particular doctrine but at the same time giving a crap about religious freedom. Also not so clear if the "freedom of belief and practice" includes the right to dis-believe, but this is a start.
I think this really interests me because it is an attempt to take on ambivalence without the need to resolve it. It's not the narrowly defined and broadly applied rhetoric usually heard from the church; the stance that somehow calls abortion a sin but allows for killing doctors who perform them. He is exploring the space where the ideal of religious freedom and a particular Catholic belief bump into each other without diminishing either. This is rare, and I think all too often we are looking for the correct answer - for resolution - rather than allowing for real inquiries into seemingly conflicting beliefs.
More than once I have had students ask me if they could believe in God and be an anthropologist. It's the cultural relativism - allowing that others have different truths - and that Christianity, Judaism, Islam, etc. are historical and cultural thought systems that get them hung up. Is it possible to understand and accept this and still believe?
But it is not just religious belief that appears to preclude the possibility of others' truths. Science is a culturally situated doctrinal knowledge system as well, and whereas we academics may be comfortable talking about an Objective Truth when multiple independent lines of evidence come together to prove a hypothesis, the important thing is to keep questioning. This includes consideration of different knowledge systems and breaking down some of these Cartesian/Durkheimian bifurcations that polarize the positions of scientist and believer. Nowhere has this been illustrated more clearly for me than in the repatriation of Native American human remains and artifacts. If there is to be a post-colonial, anti-imperial anthropology, there has to be space for the sloppiness of coexisting and often competing knowledge claims.
*pause*
This blog post is turning out a little differently than I anticipated. I guess I am a bit wrapped up in dissertation arguing mode and I somehow jumped from some random church bulletin to post-coloniality. Talk about indoctrination.
Where were we? Oh yes, holy crap found while moving. The following images are from my tenure in the book preservation/conservation department at the library. A copy of Cantigas de Santa Maria came in for repairs and I could not resist copying a few.
The devil and the courtesans were displeased because Holy Mary reformed the lustful knight...

And The devil tempted the seamstress to sew on Saturday, Holy Mary's day...

Soon to come, a look inside some boxes of fragile, sentimental things. Good to see you again, cupcakes.























































































































































